August, 2002

Are "Thief Samples" legal?

Yes! But thief samples are probably not what you think they are. A thief sampler can take a core sample of solid material either vertically (from a drum) or horizontally (from a bag). Not all thiefs look the same, but here is a rough drawing of one type.

How it works: The point is used to push through the material. The "windows" are closed when pushing through the material, then opened to allow material to flow in at the different levels. After closing the windows, the thief is pulled out.

You are probably familiar with trying to sample from a drum of liquid or solid material. With solids, scooping off the top is convenient (a "grab" sample). With liquids, using a spigot at the bottom is common. However, this type of sampling is not correct because not every part of the material in the drum has an equal chance of being in the sample. In other words, these types of samples are not random. These samples will not be representative, especially if there is variation from top to bottom due to gravitational effects on the shape, size, or density of the material.

Advantages of a thief sampler:

  • Takes material from the top, middle, and bottom.
  • Protects us in case the material varies from top to bottom.
  • Represents the whole drum better than a grab sample from the top.

Limitations of a thief sampler:

  • May be difficult to push all the way to the bottom.
  • May fill from the top before the thief gets all the way to the bottom if the windows are not sealed properly.
  • Cannot extract material at the very bottom.
  • Does not provide a true vertical core.

Moral: While a thief sampler has drawbacks, it is an improvement over grab sampling. We cannot always get a truly random sample, but we can reduce the bias in our samples by improving our equipment and procedures.

Sampling Challenge: Where did the thief sampler get its name? I don't know!! If you know or have any idea, please let me know. I'll share your knowledge with others in my next E-News.

More information about sampling equipment and procedures for solids, liquids, and gases is available in the Short Course September 16-17, 2002, at Texas Tech University and in the short introductory book A Primer for Sampling Solids, Liquids, and Gases.


Patricia L. Smith, Ph.D., Owner
Phone: 806.798.3420
Fax: 281.749.8158
E-mail: alpha@alphastat.com
Web: www.alphastat.com

Send This Information To a Friend

"Your decisions are only as good as your samples."

Sign up here to receive a quarterly one page 
E-Newsletter from Alpha Stat Consulting. 
You can unsubscribe or resubscribe at any time.
Email:

 

Newsletters | About the Owner | Bulk Sampling Short Course
Bulk Sampling
| Six Sigma | SPC, QC, QA |
Data Analysis
Implementation of Systems and Processes | Consulting  & Training | Home


E-mail: 
alpha@alphastat.com

© 2001 All Rights Reserved